Following the independent commission's bombshell verdict finding Manchester City guilty of serious financial rule breaches, the club faces the possibility of sporting sanctions that could have consequences for how its achievements are viewed.

Because the commission confirmed systematic breaches of spending limits through ‘sham’ commercial arrangements during the nine-season period from 2009/10 to 2017/18, the league's modern history hangs in the balance.

If Manchester City lose their appeal, these seven iconic moments could face renewed scrutiny or be viewed differently.

7. Mario Balotelli's "Why Always Me?" Derby Moment (2011)

The Moment: Manchester City traveled to Old Trafford and tore Manchester United apart in a historic 6-1 thrashing.

After scoring the opener, Mario Balotelli revealed an undershirt reading "Why Always Me?", a moment that signaled the official shift in football power.

The Erasure: A failed appeal could lead to renewed questions over how the financial breaches affected City's achievements during the period.

One of Old Trafford's most shocking afternoons would be reduced to an asterisked footnote of an illegitimate season.

6. Manchester City's "Centurions" Break Premier League Records (2018)

The Moment: In the 2017/18 campaign, Pep Guardiola’s side became the first and only team in English top-flight history to reach 100 points in a single season, breaking records for wins, goals, and winning margins.

The Erasure: This record-breaking season would inevitably face renewed scrutiny. Legally viewed as a byproduct of financial engineering rather than organic sporting brilliance, the "Centurions" status would be heavily compromised, potentially reopening questions over how the 2017/18 title would be treated.

5. Vincent Kompany's Manchester Derby Winner (2012)

The Moment: Weeks before the QPR drama, captain Vincent Kompany towered over United’s defense to score the only goal in a high-stakes Manchester Derby at the Etihad, putting City top of the table on goal difference.

The Erasure: Hailed as the exact second "the noisy neighbors" took real control of their destiny, a retroactively stripped 2012 season turns this high-pressure battle into a completely hollow fixture, wiping away Kompany's defining legacy moment.

4. Ilkay Gundogan's Aston Villa Comeback and Manchester City Title Win (2022)

The Moment: On the final day of the 2021/22 season, City mirrored their 2012 heroics by fighting back from 2-0 down against Aston Villa. Ilkay Gundogan scored twice in a breathless five-minute blitz to snatch the title away from Liverpool.

The Erasure: While this match sits outside the core 2009-2018 breach window, City's modern empire was constructed entirely on the foundations of that era.

If the club faces catastrophic retroactive punishments or future division expulsion, the status of City's later achievements could face renewed scrutiny.

Read More: Manchester City 115 Charges: Complete Timeline From 2018 Leaks to 2026 Verdict

Read More: Could Manchester City Lose Their 2023 Champions League Title After the 115 Charges Verdict?

3. Yaya Toure's FA Cup Final Winner Against Stoke City (2011)

The Moment: Yaya Toure smashed a ferocious second-half winner past Stoke to claim the 2011 FA Cup, ending the club's agonizing 35-year trophy drought.

The Erasure: Though a cup tie rather than a league match, the victory is widely regarded as an important moment in Manchester City's rise.

If the underlying finances backing the squad during this exact season are ruled illegitimate, the foundational trophy that broke City’s mental barrier is permanently stained.

2. Steven Gerrard's Slip Against Chelsea and Liverpool's Title Race (2014)

The Moment: Liverpool captain Steven Gerrard slipped at Anfield, allowing Chelsea’s Demba Ba to score. The slip was a pivotal moment in Liverpool's 2013/14 title race as Chelsea won 2-0 at Anfield.

The Erasure: The devastating narrative weight of this slip would vanish. If City’s 2014 title is revoked and reallocated to runners-up Liverpool, the slip did not actually cost Gerrard his elusive Premier League medal—the trophy would belong to Anfield regardless.

1. Sergio Aguero's "93:20" Premier League Title Winner Against QPR (2012)

The Moment: Trailing 2-1 in stoppage time on the final day of the 2011/12 season, Sergio Aguero smashed home a 94th-minute winner to snatch the trophy from Manchester United, immortalized by Martin Tyler's iconic scream. 

The Erasure: If the 2012 title is stripped, this goal loses its entire historical purpose. Its place as one of the Premier League's most famous title-winning moments would be viewed differently., but merely a late winner in a voided campaign, with the trophy potentially handed retrospectively to Sir Alex Ferguson’s United.